Would you breastfeed a hungry baby?
Wednesday, February 18th, 2009Last Friday I posted a bit about Whoopi Goldberg’s response to covering up the areola in a breasfeeding clip during the “Hot Topics” segment on The View. I thought I would expand on the clip itself, and pose a question to you.
On a trip to Sierra Leone, in support of a tetanus-vaccination project, Salma Hayek came across a starving baby and decided to nurse him while being filmed by ABC News. She told the camera crew that she did this in part out of compassion for a suffering child, but also to help lift the stigma against breast-feeding in Africa. Men in Africa often think women can’t have sex if they’re still nursing and pressure their wives to stop breastfeeding when few alternatives remain for safely feeding their babies.
The response to this is as can be expected. Breastfeeding advocates are praising her for promoting breastfeeding; those who are uncomfortable with breastfeeding are attacking her decision. If we think back to the earthquake in China last May, and the Chinese policewoman Jiang Xiaojuan’s heroic and emergency breastfeeding of several babies orphaned by the earthquake, we can see Salma’s act of emergency and compassionate breastfeeding is similar to policewoman Jiang Xiaojuan’s. The only difference here is the public’s response. Policewoman Jiang Xiaojuan was heralded a hero by the public; Salma is getting a mixed response, but definitely not one of unanimous hero.
Why is that? Is it because the public at large does not consider Sierra Leone to be in a state of emergency? Maybe hearing about the state of countries across Africa and their need for support has deadened our compassion? Maybe we think it’s not an emergency because it has been an ongoing issue for generations? Have we turned off our ears and closed off our hearts? Are we so jaded that we only recognize one-off environmental disasters as emergencies? Why is nursing a hungry baby more acceptable in one situation than another? Isn’t a hungry baby a hungry baby?
Personally, I love that Salma, a confessed breastfeeding addict, breastfed a hungry baby in Sierra Leone. I love that she was able to give of herself in that way and be proud of it! My question to you is, would you be able to breastfeed another woman’s baby
I would! I would not be able to deny a starving baby milk when it is something I have to offer, something I can give so easily. And yes, I would be proud of my actions as well. Of course, there are many health considerations to think about in any “wet-nursing” type situation, but a hungry baby is a baby in need. Many babies would not take another woman’s breast after having their mother’s; they do know the difference. But if the baby is happily feeding and if the the breastfeeding is consensual, would you not do the same?




